People do not resist change they were part of creating
Change initiatives fail more often than they succeed, and the reason is rarely stubborn staff. People support what they help to build. Sixty years of research point the same way.
One of the oldest and most replicated findings in organisational psychology concerns why people resist change, and the answer is less often stubbornness than lack of involvement. In a 1948 study at a Virginia textile manufacturer, researchers Lester Coch and John French compared groups of workers who were simply told about a coming change with groups who were invited to participate in planning it. The participating groups showed markedly less resistance and adapted faster, a finding that has since been generalised across decades of change management research as one of the most consistent predictors of successful implementation.
Later longitudinal research has confirmed the mechanism rather than just the outcome. Studies tracking employee attitudes over time have found that the degree of participation in a change process, along with the quality of information provided about it, is consistently associated with more favourable perceptions of that change, independent of whether the change itself was popular. In other words, people's willingness to accept a change is shaped less by the content of the decision than by whether they had a genuine hand in shaping it.
This matters because resistance is often treated by organisations as an obstacle to manage rather than as information to use. Research on participatory practices during organisational change complicates this picture usefully: it finds that participation does not simply dissolve resistance in a straightforward way, and that asking employees to participate can increase implementers' own sense of vulnerability, since it exposes decisions to challenge earlier in the process. Participation is not a technique for manufacturing consent. It is a genuine transfer of some decision-making power, and it carries real friction for the people leading the change as well as those experiencing it.
What the research suggests, taken together, is that strategies designed elsewhere and delivered to staff face a structural disadvantage regardless of their technical merit, because the people who will live with a change are also the primary source of information about what will and will not work in practice. Co-design is slower than top-down implementation. The evidence suggests it is also more durable.
References
- Coch, L. & French, J. R. P. (1948). Overcoming Resistance to Change, summarised in Springer Nature Link
- The Influence of Change-Related Organizational and Job Resources on Employee Change Engagement, Frontiers in Psychology
- Sahay, S. & Goldthwaite, C. (2024). Participatory Practices During Organizational Change: Rethinking Participation and Resistance