Compliance is the floor, not the ceiling
Compliance gives you a defensible product, not a usable one. Standards set the floor. The experience of disabled people tells you where the ceiling is.
Accessibility standards such as WCAG exist to reduce risk and establish a measurable baseline, and they do this reasonably well. What they are not designed to do, and what a substantial body of disability studies research argues they cannot do, is guarantee that a product or service is genuinely usable by the people it is meant to serve. A system can pass every automated accessibility check and still fail the people using it, because compliance testing evaluates conformance to technical criteria, not lived experience.
The disability rights movement has articulated this gap for decades through the principle "nothing about us without us": the argument that decisions affecting disabled people should not be made without their direct participation. Research in human-computer interaction has extended this into design practice specifically, with scholars critiquing empathy-driven approaches on the grounds that empathy, however well intentioned, cannot substitute for lived expertise. The recommended alternative is disability-led design, in which disabled people participate as designers, testers and decision-makers throughout the process, rather than as a consulted focus group brought in at the end.
A 2025 study working with eleven disabled families to co-design an early years support programme found that meaningful inclusion required addressing what the researchers termed institutional ableism: barriers embedded in inaccessible venues, rigid attendance policies and normative assumptions about development, none of which a standard compliance audit would catch. The solutions the co-design process generated, such as flexible attendance and facilitator training grounded in participants' own expertise, moved well beyond surface-level accommodation toward more fundamental changes to how the programme operated.
There is also evidence that this approach benefits a wider group than the one it was designed around. This effect, sometimes referred to as the curb-cut effect after the literal curb cuts originally installed for wheelchair users that ended up benefiting parents with strollers and travellers with luggage, is one reason researchers in this field frame accessibility as good design practice generally, not a niche concern. Compliance remains necessary. It reduces legal risk and gives organisations a floor to build from. But the research is fairly consistent that it should be treated as a starting point for participation, not a substitute for it.
References
- Nothing About Us, Without Us: Don't Plan About Us Without Us, Disabled World
- Remote Triggers: Misophonia, Technology Non-Use, and Design for Inclusive Digital Spaces (participatory design with disabled communities)
- Beckett, A. E. et al. (2025). Nothing About Us Without Us in the First 1000 Days: Developing Inclusive Early Years Support With Disabled Families